Lost and Found

I have several genealogical brick walls that could be broken down with just a record or two. Sadly, it almost appears as if some people were deliberately trying to hide them on me!

Even when you can find them, censuses are not the most accurate genealogical source in the world: names are badly misspelled, ages are wrong by several years, and birthplaces are inaccurate. These errors are usually not the census takers fault. When faced with a difficult name, a heavy accent, and an illiterate family who has no idea how their name is spelled then you get what you get. Also, people lie about their ages or other information, such as where their parents were born; sometimes because they simply have no idea and simply guess.

However, sometimes, the census taker were simply muddled. Or, worse, the family wasn't home and they asked the neighbours, 

A while back, I posted about my efforts to prove Sadie Simmons father. Sadie's great granddaughter, Linda, had a strong DNA match with an English family, whose roots went back past 1800 in London. This family was Jewish, as was Sadie, Linda's only known Jewish ancestor. Sadie was born in Maryland and reported multiple times that both her parents were English. Lo and behold, this family had Simmons ancestors and one of them had a son or sons who were in Maryland. So far, so good.

However, while I knew Abraham Simmons was in Maryland for many years, including the time Sadie was born, he had a large family recorded on several censuses and Sadie was not there. In fact, there was no record of Sadie at all prior to the 1900 census, when she was married and in New York. And there was no record of why she converted away from Judaism to Christianity.

My theory was that Abraham was not her father but Aaron, who also migrated to America. Aaron appears on a ship's' passenger manifest to New York in 1859 and then appears on the 1870 census in West Virginia but I had no record of him in Maryland. I guessed he was in Maryland because his brother was there but that was pure conjecture. 

Until now.

This 1860 census in Maryland has everyone we would hope to see:

• Abraham Simmons, a cigar marker
• Rachel, Abraham's wife
• Sarah, Abraham's and Rachel's oldest child
• Aaron, Abraham's brother, also a cigar maker

This information matches other records perfectly. Except their ages, which are completely out of order.

Census records almost always, 99.9% of the time, list the nuclear family from oldest to youngest, with any household inhabitants, including extended family, at the end. So the order is as we would predict, in accordance to their actual ages, but not the recorded ages.

In fact, Abraham was probably 25, Rachel was 27, Sarah was 1, and Aaron was 20. The name was also Simmons, not Simons. This name is correctly spelled on pretty much every record, probably because the Simmons were literate and could provide the correct spelling. Aaron's name is also misspelled. 

My guess is that the census taker collected the information from neighbors and botched things badly. However, this is certainly them, as the address aligns with city tax records for Abraham. 

So Aaron was in Maryland. He could have still been Sadie's father. However, Abraham also had a daughter named Sarah. While she is the wrong age, and Sadie is very consistent about her age, people have lied about their age before. Since I can't find any record of Sadie of the correct age, perhaps Sadie did lie about her age.

Or perhaps John Simmons is really her father. Abraham and Aaron did have a brother, John. And a John Simmons of the correct age, cigar maker, did migrate to America from London about the right time. Is there another Simmons in the mix?

My hunt for records continues!